Why Your Climbing Gym’s Most Important Metric Isn’t What You Think It Is
- Crushing The Crux
- By Grant Guthrie
Here is something that should trouble anyone running a climbing gym:
the person who visits twice a week, never competes, never buys a protein bar, and occasionally monopolizes the same 5.10c overhang for forty-five minutes – that person might be your most valuable asset.
Not because of what they spend. Because of what they signal.
We have become oddly obsessed, in the fitness industry, with metrics that feel rigorous because they involve division. Revenue per member. Conversion rate. Retention percentage. These numbers have the satisfying weight of mathematics behind them, which means we trust them far more than they deserve.
But consider what retention rate actually measures: whether someone didn’t leave. It’s the business equivalent of judging a restaurant by the fact that no one called an ambulance. Necessary, yes. Sufficient? Absolutely not.
The metrics worth obsessing over are the ones that measure belonging, not consumption.
Check-in frequency, tracked correctly, isn’t really about utilization – it’s a proxy for something far more interesting: whether your gym has become part of someone’s identity. There’s a meaningful difference between a member who visits because they paid for a membership and one who visits because not going feels slightly wrong. The second person will renew without being asked, refer friends without being incentivized, and forgive a bad route reset with the generosity usually reserved for close relatives.
This distinction – between a transaction and a ritual – is almost never captured in a dashboard. But it shows up in your numbers eventually, if you know where to look.
On the matter of revenue per member: the instinct is always to push this upward through upselling – classes, events, coaching. This is fine. But it misses something perverse about human psychology: people who feel they are getting slightly more than they paid for become evangelical. People who feel they are being upsold become calculating. The moment a member starts mentally auditing their membership is the moment they’re already halfway out the door.
The goal isn’t to extract maximum value from each member. It’s to make the question of value feel irrelevant.
Campaign conversion rates tell you whether your marketing worked in the narrow sense – did the ad produce a signup? But they tell you almost nothing about whether you attracted the right person. A 15% conversion rate on an audience of mildly curious gym-hoppers is considerably worse than an 8% rate on people who already have chalk on their hands and an argument ready about whether moonboard training transfers to outdoor climbing.
The best climbing gym marketing doesn’t convince people to try climbing. It finds people who already wanted to and simply hadn’t been given a sufficiently good reason to show up.
We’ve built frameworks for climbing gyms that track exactly this – the signals that predict renewal and referral behavior months before they show up in revenue. If you’re curious what that looks like for your gym, let’s talk.
Grant Guthrie
Subscribe to Crushing the Crux.
✌️ We hate spam too. Unsubscribe anytime. By clicking Submit you agree to our privacy policy.
